Wrong info on income could land politicians in jail
Mahalingam Ponnusamy TNN, 23 nov 2011, chennai edition,page no.8
Chennai: More than 50 MLAs of the previous assembly who contested in the 2011 assembly elections have not given their total income in the affidavit filed before the election commission. And legal experts say that they can be prosecuted for giving a false statement in a sworn affidavit.
Chief electoral officer Praveen Kumar insists that the total gross income should be declared in the affidavit, whereas many candidates have chosen to declare only their taxable income. Some have not declared their agricultural income, which is non-taxable.
“Anyone can file a criminal case under the Representation of the People Act, 1951, against those who produce wrong information in their affidavit and if found guilty they can be put behind bars for a year,” said chief electoral officer Praveen Kumar.
But he added that the election commission does not have any role in checking the veracity of the information filed in the affidavits.
He said that a recent Supreme Court order allows the returning officer to accept the wealth details of the candidates without verification but other grounds like age and community must be verified.
Representation of the People Act, Chapter III (electoral offences), Section 125A speaks about the penalty for filing false affidavits. The section explains that a person who “…fails to furnish information relating to subsection (1) of section 33 A (asserts) or gives false information which he knows or has reason to believe to be false, be punishable with imprisonment for a term which may extend to six months, or with fine, or with both,”
These offences are also punishable with a fine under Section 171 (G) of the Indian Penal Code that deals with elections.
D Nagasaila, an advocate with the People’s Union for Civil Liberties, said there is no mechanism to check and ensure that the data furnished by the candidates are genuine.
“Candidates feel encouraged to give wrong information since there is no follow up action on the affidavits,” Nagasaila told Times Of India.
LAWFUL ACTION
• Under the Representation of the People Act, 1951, anyone can file a criminal case against those who give wrong information in their sworn affidavit
• Section 125A of the act says if found guilty, defaulters can be put behind bars
• These offences are also punishable with a fine under Section 171 (G) of the Indian Penal Code that deals with elections
• However, the election commission does not have any role in checking the veracity of the information filed in the affidavits
• A recent SC order allows the returning officer to accept wealth details of candidates without verification but other grounds like age and community must be verified
If you have any complaint about bribe and scam for central govt CBI, Chennai,044-28255899 /28251798. FOR TN STATE DVAC Headquarters, No.293, MKN Road, Alandur, Chennai–600 016. tele +91-44-22321090 / 22321085 / 22310989 / 22342142 Fax : +91-44-22321005, E-mail: dvac@nic.in My mobile no.9884782686, 9884477807 gopalakrishnanvelu.blogspot.com, gopalakrishanvelu.blogspot.com, https://twitter.com/gopalakrishanv
Wednesday, November 23, 2011
tn, MLA income
TDS|Tax|Tamil Nadu assembly|tamil nadu|salary|RTI|MLA
In TN, MLAs’ incomes go under-reported
Mahalingam Ponnusamy, TNN |chennai edition,pageno.1 Nov 23, 2011, 01.52AM IST
CHENNAI: Income tax sleuths are known to keep a hawk eye on collecting taxes especially from businessmen and the middle class. But there is no mechanism in place to ensure that the people's representatives pay taxes on the salary they get from the government.
With tax not being deducted at source, more than half the MLAs in the last assembly who contested again this year have underreported their Rs 6 lakh-ayear salaries in the affidavits filed with the election commission. Some, however, reported receiving much more than their income from the government. Ask income tax officers about the oversight and they put the onus on the legislative assembly secretary.
In a response to an RTI query, tax officials said: "No TDS returns have been filed by the Tamil Nadu State Legislative Assembly after deduction of tax from their salary."
An MLA in the Tamil Nadu assembly typically received a gross monthly salary of nearly Rs 50,000 in 2009-2010. Some 100 MLAs contested again in the 2011 assembly elections and filed affidavits with the election commission. Of these, 53 did not mention the annual income received from the government in their affidavits and eight said they did not have a PAN (permanent account number).
Chief electoral officer Praveen Kumar told TOI that candidates should have declared their gross income in the space provided in the affidavit. Those without a PAN include transport minister V Senthil Balaji, T Velmurugan, an ex-MLA who was expelled from the PMK, and R Chinnaswamy, elected from Singanallur constituency.
Six MLAs, including PMK state president G K Mani, who had a PAN, have reported that they did not have any taxable income. But, according to the RTI response from tax officials, only around Rs 5,000 of the MLAs' income was non-taxable. When TOI contacted some of the MLAs, they said they were unaware of the tax limit and procedures.
"The government is paying salary only after deducting tax amount. There is no need to file taxes personally and I don't have any assets in my name," said T Velmurugan, whose affidavit says he neither has a PAN and nor any income. There are defaulters in all the major parties.
Fifteen DMK MLAs out of the 30 who contested in 2011, 19 from AIADMK and 13 from Congress showed their income to be less than Rs 6 lakh. Striking a different note, H Vasanthakumar and Peter Alphonse of the Congress, S R Raja and P Moorthy of the DMK, and K A Sengottaiyan of the AIADMK declared incomes of over Rs 6 lakh. Sengottaiyan has declared his family income, too, in the affidavit.
In TN, MLAs’ incomes go under-reported
Mahalingam Ponnusamy, TNN |chennai edition,pageno.1 Nov 23, 2011, 01.52AM IST
CHENNAI: Income tax sleuths are known to keep a hawk eye on collecting taxes especially from businessmen and the middle class. But there is no mechanism in place to ensure that the people's representatives pay taxes on the salary they get from the government.
With tax not being deducted at source, more than half the MLAs in the last assembly who contested again this year have underreported their Rs 6 lakh-ayear salaries in the affidavits filed with the election commission. Some, however, reported receiving much more than their income from the government. Ask income tax officers about the oversight and they put the onus on the legislative assembly secretary.
In a response to an RTI query, tax officials said: "No TDS returns have been filed by the Tamil Nadu State Legislative Assembly after deduction of tax from their salary."
An MLA in the Tamil Nadu assembly typically received a gross monthly salary of nearly Rs 50,000 in 2009-2010. Some 100 MLAs contested again in the 2011 assembly elections and filed affidavits with the election commission. Of these, 53 did not mention the annual income received from the government in their affidavits and eight said they did not have a PAN (permanent account number).
Chief electoral officer Praveen Kumar told TOI that candidates should have declared their gross income in the space provided in the affidavit. Those without a PAN include transport minister V Senthil Balaji, T Velmurugan, an ex-MLA who was expelled from the PMK, and R Chinnaswamy, elected from Singanallur constituency.
Six MLAs, including PMK state president G K Mani, who had a PAN, have reported that they did not have any taxable income. But, according to the RTI response from tax officials, only around Rs 5,000 of the MLAs' income was non-taxable. When TOI contacted some of the MLAs, they said they were unaware of the tax limit and procedures.
"The government is paying salary only after deducting tax amount. There is no need to file taxes personally and I don't have any assets in my name," said T Velmurugan, whose affidavit says he neither has a PAN and nor any income. There are defaulters in all the major parties.
Fifteen DMK MLAs out of the 30 who contested in 2011, 19 from AIADMK and 13 from Congress showed their income to be less than Rs 6 lakh. Striking a different note, H Vasanthakumar and Peter Alphonse of the Congress, S R Raja and P Moorthy of the DMK, and K A Sengottaiyan of the AIADMK declared incomes of over Rs 6 lakh. Sengottaiyan has declared his family income, too, in the affidavit.
Wednesday, November 9, 2011
RTI rulings on I-T returns not uniform
RTI rulings on I-T returns not uniform
Test Of Public Interest Is Interpreted Differently By Income Tax Officials
10th nov 2011
Mahalingam Ponnusamy TNN
Chennai: Is it possible for a citizen to access details of income tax returns filed by individuals and organizations by invoking the Right To Information (RTI) Act
The answer is both yes and no.For,too much discretion vested with the income tax authorities as well as officials designated as public information officers (PIO) under the RTI Act has resulted in utter lack of uniformity on results.
For instance,information relating to a Chennai-based charitable trust Muthamizh Peravai was furnished to RTI activists,whereas the details of IT returns filed by another trust Manitha Neyam Charitable Trust were denied to activists.Incidentally,the first trust is run by former chief minister M Karunanidhis nephew P Amirtham,whereas the second trust belongs to AIADMK leader and the new mayor of Chennai Saidai Duraisamy.
Whenever applications are filed seeking details of I-T returns of individuals or organizations,officials turn to Section 8(j) of the RTI Act for guidance.The provision says the officer could part with the information if he is satisfied that the larger public interest justifies the disclosure of such information.It also adds that information which cannot be denied to the Parliament or a state legislature,shall not be denied to any person.The assessee,whose I-T returns are sought by the applicant,too is given an opportunity to object or permit furnishing of such information.Of course,even in case of objection,the public information officer has the authority to overrule objections and disclose information.
The I-T Act accepts that the department is dutybound to supply information sought by legislature.Then,why do they hesitate to furnish the information to public, asked V Gopalakrishnan,an activist who filed an RTI application with the I-T department seeking copies of I-T returns.Recently,the department refused to furnish a copy of the I-T returns of Manitha Neayam Charitable Trust,founded and run by Chennai mayor Saidai Duraisamy and his family members.The Manitha Neayam IAS,IPS free coaching centre was established under this trust in December 2006.
In a stark contrast to this refusal,the same I-T department parted with information relating to another highprofile trust recently.Though Muthamizh Peravai at Mylapore is managed by the Kalaignar TV director and former CM Karunanidhis nephew Amirtham,activists were able to get information about its I-T returns.The annual tax returns of bigger political establishments such as the Indian National Congress (INC) too had been obtained under the RTI Act,say activists,lamenting the whimsical refusal of the I-T department to disclose information relating to Manitha Neyam Charitable Trust.
There are no clear and uniform decisions on such applications.Some public information officers at I-T department furnish the return details,but most others refuse to furnish the documents, Gopalakrishnan said.
Goplakrishnan sought the I-T returns and balance sheet submitted by the Manitha Neayam Charitable Trust from 2000 to 2011.In a reply dated October 21,the chief public information officer in I-T department said: The information sought for is filed before me in a fiduciary relationship and nothing in the (RTI) petition indicates the involvement of any larger public interest.As such,the information sough for cannot be furnished.
As per Section 138(b) of the I-T Act an income tax authority may furnish information relating to I-T returns if he is satisfied that it is in the public interest to do so.
Test Of Public Interest Is Interpreted Differently By Income Tax Officials
10th nov 2011
Mahalingam Ponnusamy TNN
Chennai: Is it possible for a citizen to access details of income tax returns filed by individuals and organizations by invoking the Right To Information (RTI) Act
The answer is both yes and no.For,too much discretion vested with the income tax authorities as well as officials designated as public information officers (PIO) under the RTI Act has resulted in utter lack of uniformity on results.
For instance,information relating to a Chennai-based charitable trust Muthamizh Peravai was furnished to RTI activists,whereas the details of IT returns filed by another trust Manitha Neyam Charitable Trust were denied to activists.Incidentally,the first trust is run by former chief minister M Karunanidhis nephew P Amirtham,whereas the second trust belongs to AIADMK leader and the new mayor of Chennai Saidai Duraisamy.
Whenever applications are filed seeking details of I-T returns of individuals or organizations,officials turn to Section 8(j) of the RTI Act for guidance.The provision says the officer could part with the information if he is satisfied that the larger public interest justifies the disclosure of such information.It also adds that information which cannot be denied to the Parliament or a state legislature,shall not be denied to any person.The assessee,whose I-T returns are sought by the applicant,too is given an opportunity to object or permit furnishing of such information.Of course,even in case of objection,the public information officer has the authority to overrule objections and disclose information.
The I-T Act accepts that the department is dutybound to supply information sought by legislature.Then,why do they hesitate to furnish the information to public, asked V Gopalakrishnan,an activist who filed an RTI application with the I-T department seeking copies of I-T returns.Recently,the department refused to furnish a copy of the I-T returns of Manitha Neayam Charitable Trust,founded and run by Chennai mayor Saidai Duraisamy and his family members.The Manitha Neayam IAS,IPS free coaching centre was established under this trust in December 2006.
In a stark contrast to this refusal,the same I-T department parted with information relating to another highprofile trust recently.Though Muthamizh Peravai at Mylapore is managed by the Kalaignar TV director and former CM Karunanidhis nephew Amirtham,activists were able to get information about its I-T returns.The annual tax returns of bigger political establishments such as the Indian National Congress (INC) too had been obtained under the RTI Act,say activists,lamenting the whimsical refusal of the I-T department to disclose information relating to Manitha Neyam Charitable Trust.
There are no clear and uniform decisions on such applications.Some public information officers at I-T department furnish the return details,but most others refuse to furnish the documents, Gopalakrishnan said.
Goplakrishnan sought the I-T returns and balance sheet submitted by the Manitha Neayam Charitable Trust from 2000 to 2011.In a reply dated October 21,the chief public information officer in I-T department said: The information sought for is filed before me in a fiduciary relationship and nothing in the (RTI) petition indicates the involvement of any larger public interest.As such,the information sough for cannot be furnished.
As per Section 138(b) of the I-T Act an income tax authority may furnish information relating to I-T returns if he is satisfied that it is in the public interest to do so.
Monday, September 19, 2011
DMK allotted plots after disbanding quota plan
Sep 19, 2011 - G. Jagannath | Age Correspondent | chennai
It has come to light that the previous DMK government allotted Tamil Nadu Housing Board (TNHB) plots to 20 persons under the government discretionary quota (GDQ) at Shollinganallur Phase-3 scheme on January 20, 2011, a week after GDQ was scrapped, as announced by the governor in his address to the Assembly.
According to the documents provided by the public information officer of TNHB’s Besant Nagar division, out of 82 allotments of plots and flats made under the GDQ since 2006, 20 were made on January 20 this year.
“The allotment is illegal since it was made after the governor’s announcement in the Assembly,” RTI activist V. Gopalakrishnan, who exposed the irregularities in the allotment of houses, flats and plots of the board under GDQ, said, demanding the cancellation of the allotments immediately.
In his customary address on January 7 this year, then governor Surjit Singh Barnala said, “The system of allotting houses and plots under the GDQ in vogue for the past several years in TNHB is being put to an end from today.” As per the system that was in vogue since 1979, 85 per cent of plots, flats or houses of the board was sold through draw of lots, which would be governed by the rules of reservation prescribed by the state government. The remaining 15 per cent was given through the GDQ.
One among the 82 beneficiaries in Shollinganallur was Union minister M.K. Alagiri’s son Dayanidhi, who got a 4,114 sq ft plot. State housing minister R. Vaithilingam told the Assembly recently that the board’s rules were violated to allot land worth `60.34 lakh at Shollinganallur to Dayan-idhi under “social worker category” on February 7, 2007. Mr Gopalakrishnan urged TNHB to cancel all the GDQ allotments after the governor’s address in January
It has come to light that the previous DMK government allotted Tamil Nadu Housing Board (TNHB) plots to 20 persons under the government discretionary quota (GDQ) at Shollinganallur Phase-3 scheme on January 20, 2011, a week after GDQ was scrapped, as announced by the governor in his address to the Assembly.
According to the documents provided by the public information officer of TNHB’s Besant Nagar division, out of 82 allotments of plots and flats made under the GDQ since 2006, 20 were made on January 20 this year.
“The allotment is illegal since it was made after the governor’s announcement in the Assembly,” RTI activist V. Gopalakrishnan, who exposed the irregularities in the allotment of houses, flats and plots of the board under GDQ, said, demanding the cancellation of the allotments immediately.
In his customary address on January 7 this year, then governor Surjit Singh Barnala said, “The system of allotting houses and plots under the GDQ in vogue for the past several years in TNHB is being put to an end from today.” As per the system that was in vogue since 1979, 85 per cent of plots, flats or houses of the board was sold through draw of lots, which would be governed by the rules of reservation prescribed by the state government. The remaining 15 per cent was given through the GDQ.
One among the 82 beneficiaries in Shollinganallur was Union minister M.K. Alagiri’s son Dayanidhi, who got a 4,114 sq ft plot. State housing minister R. Vaithilingam told the Assembly recently that the board’s rules were violated to allot land worth `60.34 lakh at Shollinganallur to Dayan-idhi under “social worker category” on February 7, 2007. Mr Gopalakrishnan urged TNHB to cancel all the GDQ allotments after the governor’s address in January
Saturday, September 17, 2011
duraisamy trust it returns
RTI Application under sec 6(1) of RTI Act-2005
From 19/09/2011
V.GOPALAKRISHNAN,
13/7, Pammal Nalla Thambi Street,
M.G.R.NAGAR,
Chennai-78.
To
The Public Information Officer,
Under Right to Information ACT 2005,
Income Tax department,
121, Aayakar Bhavan, first floor,
Nungambakkam, Chennai-34.
Sir,
Sub: Under the RTI ACT 2005 sec 6(1), request for furnish information and attested photo
copy.- regarding.
Ref:1.PIO, ITO (PR), O/o CCIT, Chennai I, Chennai-34, Lr.No.RTI/11-12/PRO date 10/06/2011.
2. PIO, circle 31(1), CR.Building, I.P.Estate, New Delhi. Lr.no.F.NO. ACIT/CIRCLE 31(1)/2011-12/101 DT 25/05/2011.
3. PIO,IT, ward III(1), salem, Lr.No.RTI/6. Ward-III(1)/SLM/ 2011-12 dated 07/06/2011.
4. Deputy Director of income tax (exemptions)-1, Ch-34, Lr.no.DDIT(E)-I/RTI/2011-12 DT 12/08/2011.
--------
1.Kindly supply copy documents submitted for registration of charitable trust under section 12A(a) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 and for grant of approval of fund under section 80G(5)(vi) of the Income Tax act, 1961. (of list of authors, list of Trustees, certified copy of Trust deed, accounts certified by charted accountant (balance sheet, receipts and payments, Account and income and expenditure account Manitha neyam charitable Trust, #28, 1st Main Road, C I T Nagar, Chennai – 600 035.
2.Kindly supply copy of income tax returns and Balance sheet submitted from year 2000-01, 2001-02, 2002-03, 2003-4, 2004-05, 2005-06,2006-2007, 2007-2008, 2008-2009, 2009-2010 and 2010-2011 by "Manitha neyam charitable Trust, #28, 1st Main Road, C I T Nagar, Chennai – 600 035 ( Manitha Neyam Trust, Approved by Ministry of Social Services, Sri Lanka - Registration no: L 30401.Registered in England and Wales - Charity no: 1085903, 501(c)(3) Tax Exempt Charity in the USA - Tax ID no: 04-3479881).
I ENCLOSED INDIAN POSTAL ORDER OF RS.10 TOWARDS RTI FEE. NO.99E 877422
ENCLOSURE: REF CITED ABOVE
V.GOPALAKRISHNAN,
From 19/09/2011
V.GOPALAKRISHNAN,
13/7, Pammal Nalla Thambi Street,
M.G.R.NAGAR,
Chennai-78.
To
The Public Information Officer,
Under Right to Information ACT 2005,
Income Tax department,
121, Aayakar Bhavan, first floor,
Nungambakkam, Chennai-34.
Sir,
Sub: Under the RTI ACT 2005 sec 6(1), request for furnish information and attested photo
copy.- regarding.
Ref:1.PIO, ITO (PR), O/o CCIT, Chennai I, Chennai-34, Lr.No.RTI/11-12/PRO date 10/06/2011.
2. PIO, circle 31(1), CR.Building, I.P.Estate, New Delhi. Lr.no.F.NO. ACIT/CIRCLE 31(1)/2011-12/101 DT 25/05/2011.
3. PIO,IT, ward III(1), salem, Lr.No.RTI/6. Ward-III(1)/SLM/ 2011-12 dated 07/06/2011.
4. Deputy Director of income tax (exemptions)-1, Ch-34, Lr.no.DDIT(E)-I/RTI/2011-12 DT 12/08/2011.
--------
1.Kindly supply copy documents submitted for registration of charitable trust under section 12A(a) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 and for grant of approval of fund under section 80G(5)(vi) of the Income Tax act, 1961. (of list of authors, list of Trustees, certified copy of Trust deed, accounts certified by charted accountant (balance sheet, receipts and payments, Account and income and expenditure account Manitha neyam charitable Trust, #28, 1st Main Road, C I T Nagar, Chennai – 600 035.
2.Kindly supply copy of income tax returns and Balance sheet submitted from year 2000-01, 2001-02, 2002-03, 2003-4, 2004-05, 2005-06,2006-2007, 2007-2008, 2008-2009, 2009-2010 and 2010-2011 by "Manitha neyam charitable Trust, #28, 1st Main Road, C I T Nagar, Chennai – 600 035 ( Manitha Neyam Trust, Approved by Ministry of Social Services, Sri Lanka - Registration no: L 30401.Registered in England and Wales - Charity no: 1085903, 501(c)(3) Tax Exempt Charity in the USA - Tax ID no: 04-3479881).
I ENCLOSED INDIAN POSTAL ORDER OF RS.10 TOWARDS RTI FEE. NO.99E 877422
ENCLOSURE: REF CITED ABOVE
V.GOPALAKRISHNAN,
duraisamy AIADMK IT returns
RTI Application under sec 6(1) of RTI Act-2005
From 19/09/2011
V.GOPALAKRISHNAN,
13/7, Pammal Nalla Thambi Street,
M.G.R.NAGAR,
Chennai-78.
To
The Public Information Officer,
Under Right to Information ACT 2005,
Income Tax department,
121, Aayakar Bhavan, first floor,
Nungambakkam, Chennai-34.
Sir,
Sub: Under the RTI ACT 2005 sec 6(1), request for furnish information and attested photo
copy.- regarding.
Ref:1.PIO, ITO (PR), O/o CCIT, Chennai I, Chennai-34, Lr.No.RTI/11-12/PRO date 10/06/2011.
2. PIO, circle 31(1), CR.Building, I.P.Estate, New Delhi. Lr.no.F.NO. ACIT/CIRCLE 31(1)/2011-12/101 DT 25/05/2011.
3. PIO,IT, ward III(1), salem, Lr.No.RTI/6. Ward-III(1)/SLM/ 2011-12 dated 07/06/2011.
4. Deputy Director of income tax (exemptions)-1, Ch-34, Lr.no.DDIT(E)-I/RTI/2011-12 DT 12/08/2011.
--------
1. Kindly supply copy of income tax returns and Balance sheet submitted from year 2000-01, 2001-02, 2002-03, 2003-4, 2004-05, 2005-06,2006-2007, 2007-2008, 2008-2009, 2009-2010 and 2010-2011 by S. Duraisamy s/o samyappan, pan no.AFUPD6476L.
2. Kindly supply copy of income tax returns and Balance sheet submitted from year 2000-01, 2001-02, 2002-03, 2003-4, 2004-05, 2005-06,2006-2007, 2007-2008, 2008-2009, 2009-2010 and 2010-2011 by Maliga Duraisamy, pan no.AEOPM0212L.
I ENCLOSED INDIAN POSTAL ORDER OF RS.10 TOWARDS RTI FEE. NO.99E 877423
Encolsed reference above cited
V.GOPALAKRISHNAN,
From 19/09/2011
V.GOPALAKRISHNAN,
13/7, Pammal Nalla Thambi Street,
M.G.R.NAGAR,
Chennai-78.
To
The Public Information Officer,
Under Right to Information ACT 2005,
Income Tax department,
121, Aayakar Bhavan, first floor,
Nungambakkam, Chennai-34.
Sir,
Sub: Under the RTI ACT 2005 sec 6(1), request for furnish information and attested photo
copy.- regarding.
Ref:1.PIO, ITO (PR), O/o CCIT, Chennai I, Chennai-34, Lr.No.RTI/11-12/PRO date 10/06/2011.
2. PIO, circle 31(1), CR.Building, I.P.Estate, New Delhi. Lr.no.F.NO. ACIT/CIRCLE 31(1)/2011-12/101 DT 25/05/2011.
3. PIO,IT, ward III(1), salem, Lr.No.RTI/6. Ward-III(1)/SLM/ 2011-12 dated 07/06/2011.
4. Deputy Director of income tax (exemptions)-1, Ch-34, Lr.no.DDIT(E)-I/RTI/2011-12 DT 12/08/2011.
--------
1. Kindly supply copy of income tax returns and Balance sheet submitted from year 2000-01, 2001-02, 2002-03, 2003-4, 2004-05, 2005-06,2006-2007, 2007-2008, 2008-2009, 2009-2010 and 2010-2011 by S. Duraisamy s/o samyappan, pan no.AFUPD6476L.
2. Kindly supply copy of income tax returns and Balance sheet submitted from year 2000-01, 2001-02, 2002-03, 2003-4, 2004-05, 2005-06,2006-2007, 2007-2008, 2008-2009, 2009-2010 and 2010-2011 by Maliga Duraisamy, pan no.AEOPM0212L.
I ENCLOSED INDIAN POSTAL ORDER OF RS.10 TOWARDS RTI FEE. NO.99E 877423
Encolsed reference above cited
V.GOPALAKRISHNAN,
Friday, September 16, 2011
Plot for Alagiris son under scanner
Plot for Alagiris son under scanner
Mahalingam Ponnusamy TNN
Chennai: Durai Dayanidhi,son of Union minister M K Alagiri,is under the state government scanner for getting a plot from the Tamil Nadu Housing Board (TNHB) under the governments discretionary quota (GDQ) during the DMK regime claiming that he was a social worker.
Documents with TOI show that the ministers son had declared in his TNHB application in 2007 that neither he nor his family owned a residence or plot anywhere.But an affidavit that Alagiri filed while contesting the 2009 Lok Sabha elections lists two plots in the name of Dayanidhi in Chennai one worth Rs 36.38 lakh on Tiger Varadachariyar Road in Tiruvanmiyur and another worth Rs 1.96 crore on Beemanna Mudali Street in Mylapore,besides a farmhouse at Etchambakkam in Tambaram taluk and a house in Kodaikanal.
The encumbrance certificate for the Tiruvanmiyur property obtained by TOI shows that it was bought by Alagiri on March 24,2004,in Dayanidhis name.The certificate shows the value of the property as Rs 97.65 lakh.The first purchaser,A Ramachandran,bought the unoccupied plot from the Tamil Nadu Housing Board on February 5,2004,and a month later transferred it to Dayanidhi.Alagiri signed the sale agreement as Dayanidhi was a minor then.
ATNHB reply to an RTI application shows that Dayanidhi concealed this information to buy a 4,114-sqft plot from the TNHB at Sholinganallur in Kancheepuram district under the GDQ in 2007.Such allotment is done only for people who dont own a residence or land in corporation limits or first and special grade municipalities.To buy the land,Dayanidhi apparently gave a false affidavit,saying he or his family members didnt own a house or plot.Alagiris affidavit says he owns four plots and three houses,while his wife has five plots,two commercial buildings and a flat at Madhavaram.
The allotment was made through a government order (No.36) of the housing and urban development department on February 2,2007.As per TNHB rules,the allotment would stand cancelled if it is proved that the applicant gave wrong information to obtain it.
V Gopalakrishnan,an RTI activist who collected the documents,said Dayanidhi got the allotment under the social worker category though he is a businessman,with a partnership in film production house Cloud Nine Movies.
Landing in trouble
Durai Dayanidhi bought 4,114sqft plot from TNHB in Sholinganallur
In 2007,he gave an affidavit saying he or his family members did not own a house/plot
But MK Alagiris election affidavit in 2009 listed four properties in Dayanidhis name
These include two plots in Chennai,a farmhouse in Tambaram & a house in Kodaikanal
Alagiri son paid.24L for land
Dayanidhi paid Rs 24,13,800 as initial deposit for the allotment and continued paying Rs 68,600 a month to clear the balance dues.He mentioned his annualincome asonly Rs 9 lakh in the application form.The government never bothered to check if the applicant owned a residence.Most of the allotments were made without assessing the repaying capacity of the applicant, said Gopalakrishnan.
The TNHB,which has a large land bank,had the GDQ system,under which 15% of allotments could be done by the government.Single /deserted women,widows,social workers,physically handicapped persons,defence personnel,ex-servicemen,eminent persons in the field of science,arts,literature,economics,public administration and sports,freedom fighters;government servants with unblemished service records,employees of PSUs,central government undertakings and nationalized banks,PF institutions,journalists,university staff,and employees of local bodies and municipalities were eligible for getting allocations under the GDQ.The quota was scrapped by the erstwhile DMK government earlier this year after the housing board land allocation scam broke out.
Mahalingam Ponnusamy TNN
Chennai: Durai Dayanidhi,son of Union minister M K Alagiri,is under the state government scanner for getting a plot from the Tamil Nadu Housing Board (TNHB) under the governments discretionary quota (GDQ) during the DMK regime claiming that he was a social worker.
Documents with TOI show that the ministers son had declared in his TNHB application in 2007 that neither he nor his family owned a residence or plot anywhere.But an affidavit that Alagiri filed while contesting the 2009 Lok Sabha elections lists two plots in the name of Dayanidhi in Chennai one worth Rs 36.38 lakh on Tiger Varadachariyar Road in Tiruvanmiyur and another worth Rs 1.96 crore on Beemanna Mudali Street in Mylapore,besides a farmhouse at Etchambakkam in Tambaram taluk and a house in Kodaikanal.
The encumbrance certificate for the Tiruvanmiyur property obtained by TOI shows that it was bought by Alagiri on March 24,2004,in Dayanidhis name.The certificate shows the value of the property as Rs 97.65 lakh.The first purchaser,A Ramachandran,bought the unoccupied plot from the Tamil Nadu Housing Board on February 5,2004,and a month later transferred it to Dayanidhi.Alagiri signed the sale agreement as Dayanidhi was a minor then.
ATNHB reply to an RTI application shows that Dayanidhi concealed this information to buy a 4,114-sqft plot from the TNHB at Sholinganallur in Kancheepuram district under the GDQ in 2007.Such allotment is done only for people who dont own a residence or land in corporation limits or first and special grade municipalities.To buy the land,Dayanidhi apparently gave a false affidavit,saying he or his family members didnt own a house or plot.Alagiris affidavit says he owns four plots and three houses,while his wife has five plots,two commercial buildings and a flat at Madhavaram.
The allotment was made through a government order (No.36) of the housing and urban development department on February 2,2007.As per TNHB rules,the allotment would stand cancelled if it is proved that the applicant gave wrong information to obtain it.
V Gopalakrishnan,an RTI activist who collected the documents,said Dayanidhi got the allotment under the social worker category though he is a businessman,with a partnership in film production house Cloud Nine Movies.
Landing in trouble
Durai Dayanidhi bought 4,114sqft plot from TNHB in Sholinganallur
In 2007,he gave an affidavit saying he or his family members did not own a house/plot
But MK Alagiris election affidavit in 2009 listed four properties in Dayanidhis name
These include two plots in Chennai,a farmhouse in Tambaram & a house in Kodaikanal
Alagiri son paid.24L for land
Dayanidhi paid Rs 24,13,800 as initial deposit for the allotment and continued paying Rs 68,600 a month to clear the balance dues.He mentioned his annualincome asonly Rs 9 lakh in the application form.The government never bothered to check if the applicant owned a residence.Most of the allotments were made without assessing the repaying capacity of the applicant, said Gopalakrishnan.
The TNHB,which has a large land bank,had the GDQ system,under which 15% of allotments could be done by the government.Single /deserted women,widows,social workers,physically handicapped persons,defence personnel,ex-servicemen,eminent persons in the field of science,arts,literature,economics,public administration and sports,freedom fighters;government servants with unblemished service records,employees of PSUs,central government undertakings and nationalized banks,PF institutions,journalists,university staff,and employees of local bodies and municipalities were eligible for getting allocations under the GDQ.The quota was scrapped by the erstwhile DMK government earlier this year after the housing board land allocation scam broke out.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)